What storm damage looks like on a roof
Wind and hail leave different marks, and neither is always obvious from the driveway.
Wind damage usually shows up as missing shingles, tabs that are creased or folded back, or shingles that have come unsealed and lift in a breeze. Ridge caps and the edges of the roof take the most wind. A creased shingle may look flat today and leak next month.
Hail damage on asphalt shingles shows up as soft, dark spots where granules have been knocked loose, sometimes with a bruise you can feel by pressing. Dents in gutters, downspouts, metal vents and window wraps are a good clue that the roof took hits too. Hail can also crack vinyl siding and the fins on an air conditioner.
Fallen limbs can puncture the deck outright. That's an emergency tarp situation.
Southwest Michigan gets this kind of weather most years. Kalamazoo County has had notable hail in past seasons, and on May 7, 2024, an EF2 tornado tore through Portage and the surrounding area, destroying homes and damaging the FedEx facility. Most storm claims come from far less dramatic weather than that.
What to do right after a storm
- Stay off the roof. Wet shingles, loose debris and hidden damage make it dangerous.
- Take photos of damage you can see from the ground, inside water stains, dented gutters and anything that fell, with the date.
- Stop water coming in. If there's an active leak or a hole, a roofer can put on a temporary tarp. Keep the receipt.
- Call your insurance company or agent to report the damage and ask how they want you to proceed. Read your policy's section on roof coverage and deductibles.
- Get a local roofer to inspect and give you a written report and estimate.
How a roofer fits into an insurance claim
We can't give insurance or legal advice, and your policy and your insurer make the coverage decisions. In general, here's how a local roofer can help:
- Inspect the roof and document damage with photos
- Write an itemized estimate of the repair or replacement
- Meet your adjuster on the roof, if you want them there, so both are looking at the same thing
- Do the work once you've decided how to proceed
Things a roofer shouldn't do: promise that insurance will buy you a "free roof," offer to cover or waive your deductible, or ask you to sign over your claim before you understand what you're signing. If an estimate or a settlement doesn't make sense to you, ask your insurer to explain it. Michigan's Department of Insurance and Financial Services (DIFS) takes consumer questions and complaints about insurers.
The Michigan Attorney General's office also suggests asking your insurer to make claim checks payable to you, not directly to a contractor.
How to spot a storm chaser
Storm chasers follow hail reports from state to state. Not every out-of-town crew is bad, but the warning signs are consistent:
- Door-to-door pitch right after the storm, often with a "we're working in your neighborhood" line
- Pressure to sign today, or a contract that's mostly about your insurance claim rather than the work
- No Michigan license number, or a license under a different company name
- A large cash deposit
- No local address or phone number you can check
Ask for a Michigan residential builder or maintenance and alteration contractor license number and look it up with LARA. Ask for proof of insurance. Ask who will honor the workmanship warranty a year from now, and where they'll be.
If you sign a contract with a door-to-door seller at your home, Michigan's Home Solicitation Sales Act may give you a short window to cancel. Whether it applies depends on how the sale happened, so check with the Attorney General's consumer protection office if you're unsure.
Repair or replace after a storm?
It depends on how widespread the damage is, how old the roof was, and whether matching shingles are available. See our pages on roof repair and roof replacement. If you just want to know whether there's damage at all, start with a roof inspection.
Storm work around the county
We connect homeowners with local roofers after storms in Portage, Texas Township, and the rest of Kalamazoo County. Hail-dented gutters are often part of the same claim; see our gutters page.